7 Brew Christmas Drinks (Copycat Holiday Menu at Home)
Quick answer
Brew strong coffee or espresso, then stir in the flavored syrups and steamed milk for each drink: peppermint and chocolate for the mocha, cinnamon and vanilla for the sugar cookie latte, white chocolate and eggnog for the chiller. Top with whipped cream and a sprinkle of crushed candy cane or cinnamon. Three drinks, one pot of coffee.
7 Brew Christmas drinks are the sweet, creamy holiday coffees from the drive thru, made at home for a fraction of the price. One pot of strong coffee makes all three: a peppermint mocha, a cinnamon sugar cookie latte and a white chocolate eggnog chiller. Each one takes about 5 minutes once the coffee is brewed, and the whole menu suits a slow December morning or a holiday brunch table.
Why you’ll love it
- Three holiday drinks from one pot of coffee.
- No espresso machine needed, strong brewed coffee works.
- Each drink takes about 5 minutes once the coffee is brewed.
- Sweet and creamy, just like the drive thru version.
- A fun holiday brunch menu that guests can mix and match.
Ingredient notes
Strong coffee: the base. Brew it with double the grounds so the coffee flavor survives the milk, syrups and eggnog. Weak coffee disappears into sweet milk, and the drink tastes flat.
Chocolate syrup and peppermint: the mocha. Chocolate syrup dissolves easily in hot coffee, and half a teaspoon of peppermint extract gives a clean, cool mint note. Real extract beats syrup here, since syrup makes the drink too sweet.
Brown sugar and cinnamon: the sugar cookie latte. Brown sugar melts into the hot coffee and gives a warm, caramel note, while cinnamon and vanilla make it taste like a fresh sugar cookie.
White chocolate and eggnog: the chiller. Melted white chocolate gives the iced drink a rich, creamy body, and chilled eggnog brings the holiday spice. Cool the coffee first, since hot coffee curdles eggnog.
The strong coffee rule that makes or breaks it
One rule decides all three drinks: brew the coffee strong. The milk, syrups and eggnog all dilute the coffee, so a regular brew disappears and the drink tastes like sweet milk with a coffee rumor in it. Double the grounds, keep the coffee hot for the two hot drinks, and set one third aside to cool for the chiller. The second half of the rule is the milk. Steam it until it is hot and silky, but never boil it, since boiled milk tastes flat and scorched. Get the coffee and the milk right and every drink on the menu tastes like the drive thru made it.
Variations
- Iced peppermint mocha: pour the mocha over ice instead of adding steamed milk for a cold version that suits a warm December afternoon.
- Caramel sugar cookie latte: swap the brown sugar for caramel sauce and top with a caramel drizzle for a richer latte.
- Spiced eggnog chiller: add a pinch of cinnamon and a dash of vanilla to the eggnog mix for a warmer spice flavor.
- Decaf holiday menu: brew decaf coffee the same way for an evening version that still tastes like the holiday menu.
What we learned testing it
- Strong coffee beat regular coffee clearly. The strong brew kept its coffee flavor under the milk and syrups, while the regular brew disappeared into sweet milk.
- Real peppermint extract beat peppermint syrup in the mocha test. The extract gave a clean, cool mint note, while the syrup made the drink too sweet and muddy.
- Melted white chocolate beat white chocolate syrup for the chiller. The melted chips gave a rich, creamy body, while the syrup tasted thin and left the drink watery.
Read how we test recipes.
7 Brew Christmas Drinks (Copycat Holiday Menu at Home)
Makes 3 holiday coffee drinks · 20 min total · Easy
Ingredients
For the peppermint mocha
For the cinnamon sugar cookie latte
For the white chocolate eggnog chiller
Equipment
Coffee maker or espresso machine · Milk frother or small saucepan · Mugs · Spoons · Measuring spoons
Instructions
-
Brew the coffee base
Brew 1 1/2 cups of strong coffee, or pull 6 shots of espresso, and keep it hot. Strong coffee is the key here, since the milk, syrups and eggnog all dilute it. Weak coffee makes a drink that tastes like sweet milk. Split the hot coffee evenly between three mugs for the two hot drinks, and set one third aside to cool for the chiller.
-
Build the peppermint mocha
Stir the chocolate syrup and peppermint extract into the first mug of hot coffee until the syrup dissolves. Pour in the steamed milk, stir once, and top with a swirl of whipped cream and a sprinkle of crushed candy canes. The peppermint should be a cool note behind the chocolate, not the main flavor.
-
Build the cinnamon sugar cookie latte
Stir the brown sugar, cinnamon and vanilla into the second mug of hot coffee until the sugar dissolves. Pour in the steamed milk, stir once, and top with whipped cream and a dusting of cinnamon sugar. It should taste like a warm sugar cookie in a mug, sweet and spiced, with the coffee underneath.
-
Build the eggnog chiller and serve
Melt the white chocolate chips into the cooled coffee, then stir in the chilled eggnog. Fill a tall glass with ice, pour the mix over it, and top with whipped cream and a pinch of nutmeg. Serve all three drinks right away, while the hot ones are hot and the chiller is still icy.
Notes
- Brew the coffee strong. The milk, syrups and eggnog all dilute it, so weak coffee makes a drink that tastes like sweet milk.
- Steam the milk, do not boil it. Boiled milk tastes flat and scorched, while steamed milk is sweet and silky.
- Cool the coffee for the chiller before adding the eggnog. Hot coffee curdles eggnog, while cooled coffee mixes in smoothly.
- Taste before topping. The syrups vary in sweetness, so adjust the sugar and peppermint to your taste before the whipped cream goes on.
Nutrition per serving
Nutrition information is being calculated.
Substitutions
- Whole milk
- Use oat milk, almond milk or any milk you like instead. Oat milk steams the creamiest of the dairy free options, and it suits the sugar cookie latte best.
- Eggnog
- Use 1/2 cup of milk with 1/4 teaspoon of nutmeg and 1 tablespoon of sugar instead. It will not be as rich as eggnog, but it keeps the same holiday spice.
- Espresso
- Use 1 1/2 cups of very strong brewed coffee instead. Double the grounds you would normally use, so the coffee flavor survives the milk and syrups.
Storage and make-ahead
These drinks are best made fresh and served right away. The hot drinks keep in a thermos for up to 1 hour. The chiller does not keep, since the ice melts and waters it down. Store leftover syrup mixes in the fridge for up to 3 days and reheat them with fresh coffee.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best 7 Brew Christmas drinks to make at home?
The peppermint mocha, the cinnamon sugar cookie latte and the white chocolate eggnog chiller cover the holiday menu. One pot of strong coffee makes all three, and each one takes about 5 minutes once the coffee is brewed.
Can I make 7 Brew Christmas drinks without an espresso machine?
Yes. Brew very strong coffee with double the grounds you would normally use. It gives the same bold coffee base, and the milk and syrups do the rest of the work.
How do I make the eggnog chiller without curdling the eggnog?
Cool the coffee first. Hot coffee curdles eggnog, so let the brewed coffee cool to warm or room temperature, melt in the white chocolate, then stir in the chilled eggnog and pour it over ice.
Can I make these Christmas coffee drinks ahead of time?
The hot drinks keep in a thermos for up to 1 hour. The chiller does not keep, since the ice melts. Brew the coffee ahead and build each drink fresh when you want it.
What milk works best for 7 Brew copycat drinks?
Whole milk steams the creamiest and tastes the richest. Oat milk is the best dairy free choice, since it steams well and suits the sugar cookie latte. Almond milk works too, but it steams thinner.